For years, the conversation around manufacturing recruitment has centred on one thing: finding people.
But after speaking with 40 manufacturing leaders across the UK, one thing became clear. The real workforce crisis isn't simply a lack of candidates. It's a much deeper issue affecting recruitment, retention, leadership and long-term business growth. At Westray Recruitment Group, we believe understanding the problem is the first step towards solving it.
Many businesses believe the biggest challenge is attracting applicants.
The research suggests otherwise.
Half of manufacturing leaders told us their biggest concern is workforce availability and reliability, while only 30% pointed to skills shortages and 20% cited resource management.
That shift is significant.
Manufacturers are no longer struggling to receive applications. They're struggling to build reliable teams that consistently turn up, perform well and stay with the business. This is why recruitment can no longer be viewed as simply filling vacancies. It has become a workforce strategy.
When people hear "skills shortage", they often think about welders, electricians or CNC machinists. However, our research uncovered something different. 60% of manufacturing leaders said soft skills such as reliability, communication, initiative and problem solving are now harder to find than technical ability. Only 10% identified shortages in specific technical occupations as their greatest challenge.
Technical skills can often be developed through training.
Attitude, commitment and cultural fit are far more difficult to teach.
For manufacturers, that changes how recruitment should be approached.
One of the strongest themes throughout the research was leadership. Many businesses continue promoting excellent operators into supervisory positions without giving them the training to become effective people managers.
The result?
Poor communication, inconsistent management and lower employee engagement.
When supervisors lack the skills to motivate, coach and support their teams, retention suffers. In many cases, investing in leadership development may deliver a greater return than investing solely in recruitment.
Today's candidates have more choice. That means every interaction shapes your employer brand.
Our research found that 85% of manufacturers receive no feedback from candidates about their hiring or onboarding process, leaving many businesses unaware of the barriers preventing them from securing top talent.
Among those who did receive feedback, the recurring themes were:
Improving candidate experience isn't just good recruitment practice. It's becoming a competitive advantage.
Hiring the wrong person doesn't just leave another vacancy.
It affects productivity, morale, training costs, operational performance and future workforce planning. Existing employees often have to absorb additional responsibilities while businesses begin the recruitment process all over again.
The true cost of poor recruitment is often hidden. That's why the businesses performing best aren't relying on recruitment alone. They're investing in onboarding, development, leadership and long-term workforce planning.
The encouraging news is that manufacturers believe many of these challenges can be solved.
In fact, 70% of leaders identified training and development as the most effective way to strengthen workforce capability and close skills gaps.
The organisations getting ahead are:
These businesses recognise that sustainable growth comes from building stronger teams, not simply hiring more people.
The workforce crisis facing manufacturing is more complex than many businesses realise. Recruitment is only one part of the solution.
More blog postsA representative from Westray will be in touch with you shortly.